Wednesday, 26 January 2011

Egypt's Tweets of Rage

'Le Sphinx Armachis, Caire' (The Sphinx Armach...Image by National Media Museum via FlickrEgypt's Day of Rage unfolded yesterday afternoon, the news of gathering crowds and images of protesters heading for Tahrir square shared over Twitter by activists and people in general in a fascinating, blow-by-blow (later on, literally) account. I can't find Ramadan Al Sherbini's lead story from Gulf News online today, so here's a link to another of his stories on the protests.

As before, with events in Iran (which I wrote about extensively in relation to the role of social and mainstream media, you can get the backstory here if you like), the information flow quickly became cluttered with a mixture of retweets, Twibbons and other outside voices clogging up the #Jan25 and #Egypt hashtags.

However, as before, those of us following a number of people in Egypt had access to reliable, first-hand information and were able to watch the story unfold. As the afternoon wore on, mobile networks went down around Tahrir - the government was blamed for the outage, but operators are insisting it was their networks at fault - and vendors around the square, caf├ęs and the like, took the password protection off their wireless networks so people could continue to get word out. There were widespread reports that the government had blocked Twitter, but this is a technically aware generation, people - access was obtained using different clients and proxies.

Mainstream media got access to events through Twitter too - sometimes even quoting the Tweets of journalists on the stweets such as this example from the Wall Street Journal. Such a huge repository of eye witness reports makes for a fascinating account of events - and, importantly, creates awareness and publicises the protest. This post, from Global Voices, shows how Tweets can be used with devastating effect in reportage. There were a lot of brave journalists among the crowds, including Al Jazeerah's cameraman, who was hospitalised with four rubber-cased bullets lodged in his arm as police tried to break up the demonstrations.

Twitter was also being used as an organising tool, with people able to share information widely - when you tweet to a popular and timely hashtag, you're effectively multicasting. And it's being used to get word out this morning, as a second day of demonstrations appears to be on the cards.

There has been a lot of debate over the role of social media, particularly Facebook and Twitter, in Tunisia and, prior to that, Iran, both in terms of quite how fundamental both were to events and how reliable reports were. Without a doubt, the closer you are to an event, the more reliable Twitter becomes - by closer, I mean that you have established relationships with people of reputation on the ground or, at the most, at a second remove. Once you get past the third degree of separation, you're losing eyewitness credibility and getting bogged down under the hashtag traffic. But you're also seeing a world that has had its attention brought to the Jan 25 protests and reacting overwhelmingly in support of the protestors, something that Tunisia hacked Facebook to stop and that Egypt appears to have blocked Twitter to stop.

Blocking Twitter won't stop word getting out. You're as well to try and stop grains of sand falling through marbles. Here, for your amusement, is the official word from the Egyptian State Information Service. Compare it to #Jan25 and enjoy.
Enhanced by Zemanta


Mich said...

By the way, did you catch the Image Feed Aggregator for #jan25 created yesterday by Lebanese tweeps and IT professionals @migheille and @nightS?

They said: "Due to the lack of media coverage of the events and protests that are taking place in Egypt at the moment,we(@migheille and @nightS) set up this feed aggregator to help spreading the word by posting images taken by protesters from the ground. Images from twitpic and yfrog by protesters are being fetched and posted here in one place," they said.


Thought it was extremely interesting and clever! :-)

Justin said...

Good post Andrew – a nice summary of the use of Twitter during the Egypt’s protests yesterday. Your point about “how close” you are to the event the more reliable and trustworthy your tweets are is spot on.

Inaccuracy and hyperbole are, via the format of Twitter and the #hashtag conversation, so easily spread – especially during such highly visible events. An example of this is a recent, quite amusing, tweet flow from London LINK:

One misinterpreted tweet lead to a rapid and wide spread proliferation of rumor (a shooting on London Oxford Street) that lead to traditional media investigating the claims (I believe some local media actually reported as fact).

This is obviously just one small, all be it nicely contained, example.

It can be hard with the noise and volume of twitter to be able to identify the truths from the half-truths or lies. That being said its power as a global platform to give people a voice and for the truths to bubble to the surface is awesome to behold.

Good stuff.

Justin said...

I do of course mean Alexander not Andrew!. Sorry about that, not enough coffee drunk today.

Roba said...

The saddest part about the blocking of the Internet is that the world seems to be okay with it.

It just confirms what we already knew. The West, i.e. America, only cares about "democracy" and "freedom of speech" and all the load of bullshit they try to export when it is good for them and Israel.

"Oh, don't be violent, our precious little child! You are hurting them, now go kiss and make up. You don't want to? That's fine, but at least give them their toy back. Oh, you're so precious!"

In the end, I believe, the situation wouldn't have had as many causalities if communication with the world was not blocked.

From The Dungeons

Book Marketing And McNabb's Theory Of Multitouch

(Photo credit: Wikipedia ) I clearly want to tell the world about A Decent Bomber . This is perfectly natural, it's my latest...