Tuesday, 29 July 2008


Very Long Post Warning

I’m sure there have been gigabytes written on this topic, but I somehow feel the need to add to the weighty wodge that’s clogging up the useful stuff (like this) flowing around the Internet.

What should you do if a blog slags off your company or makes snarky comments about your customer service? What are your rights and how can you fix the damage? Here’s a handy ten point guide for companies that feel themselves wronged by blogs. And it's FREE! It might even help the smattering of dorks that have tried to ‘right wrongs’ on this blog by posting inane comments from behind their corporate firewalls.

1. Think
Before you rush to make a dim-witted comment on the blog, think about it. What has the blogger said that you disagree with? Is it an opinion or a factual error? Can you back up your assertion that there is a fundamental error? Can you provide evidence that the opinion expressed is ill-founded or at odds with the majority of people? If you work with a PR or communications agency, get their counsel before you act.

2. Remember: it’s a conversation
If you’re being attacked by blogs, it may be worth taking a look at the situation they’re highlighting and seeing if the point is valid and addressable – and then addressing it before going online and saying so. If the attack is invalid, then it’s worth acknowledging the point that’s been made before making your, well-argued, counterpoint in a measured, respectful way. The more aggressive the blogger, the more a measured tone will position you as the reasonable and authoritative participant in the conversation. It’s literally just like a face to face conversation – and wagging fingers or shouting will just get people’s backs up – even if in response to someone who’s obviously infuriated. Think how you’d behave in a customer service situation. Well, bloggers are just customers with an audience.

3. Most blogs don’t matter
Before you go making a great big song and dance, consider doing absolutely nothing. Most blogs are read by an average 1.1 people – the 1 being the blogger. Is the blog well respected and well read? Will it influence opinion? Just because someone in the company has emailed a link to the blog around every member of the management team doesn’t mean that the blog is normally well read. And a few hundred visits to a marginal blog prompted by that email, by the way, will just let the blogger know that they’re onto something that gets them more readers. So they’ll likely do more of it, not less.

4. Blogs can matter very quickly
I’m going to be very Delphic now. In deciding to ignore a blog, do bear in mind that blogs can go from zero to hero in absolutely no time. A lot of today’s journalists spend a lot of time on blogs and the oddest things can result in a huge amount of interest. Take a look at this blog, a case study of how a blog can make a fundamental difference – and do note that this is case study from the Middle East. There have been instances of a blog post making national front page headlines within 48 hours in Europe and gaining over 2 million readers as a consequence. And then there are companies that have turned expressions of customer dissatisfaction made on blogs completely to their advantage. The success story is built around actually listening to what people are saying, not ignoring it.

5. Don’t hide your identity
Like the Ray Bans ad says: don’t hide. There may be an urge to post a positive, balancing comment on the blog under an anonymous handle or a pseudonym. Do be aware that most bloggers have access to tools that allow them to track back visitors to the blog. You make a comment on my blog? I know who you are. So if you work for a major daily newspaper or a telco and you don’t like what I’ve got to say, have the guts to say so under your own name. Because I’ll know anyway and just ‘out’ you for being a custard. And so will most other people who write blogs.

6. Find out who the blogger is
No, I don’t mean set the secret service on ‘em. I mean take the time to read some of the blog at least, look at past posts and comments and see if the blogger is authoritative or a loose cannon. There’s nothing more awful than watching some corporate flak try to make a fool out of a widely respected expert because they didn’t bother finding out who the blogger was – regardless of whether they blog under their own names or pseudonyms, bloggers have an ‘identity’ in the overall conversation. Take a look at the blogs that link to/are linked to out of the blog. Look at Technorati and find the blog’s rating. Perhaps do a google or two and find out how the blog ranks on search. Authority is about tone, resonance and reach.

7. Take some time out to understand blogs in general
Know what a troll is? Or a trackback link? Understand the importance of RSS and feed readers? Know what IMHO stands for? If not, find a younger member of your staff and get them to explain it all to you before you start blundering around crashing conversations. By the way, if you want to know what blogs are saying about your company, consider setting up a Google alert.

8. Don’t crash the conversation
Think of it all like you’d think about joining a real-life conversation. In posting to my blog, I’m putting something into the public domain that I think people will find interesting or that I just want to get off my chest. Usually both! It’s a bit like standing on a soap box. People are kind enough to drop by and listen to me – some have a chat with me at the end of the lecture. And I go to their lectures too – to listen and have a chat afterwards. It’s all pretty civilised most of the time. It’s relatively easy to join the conversation as long as you don’t crash in without having bothered to listen to the preceding debate. Again, just as in real life you wouldn’t rudely barge into a group and vent your opinion on a topic without taking the time to find out what the prevailing opinion and tone of debate was like. Well, not unless you want the group to all round on you and tell you to shove off, that is...

9. You can’t make it go away
Barring access to a blog from the corporate network because it has attacked your company will just ensure all your staff go home and take a look at what all the fuss is about. I worked with one company that did just that, in the face of our advice, and we watched in frustration as they embarked on a futile and highly visible witch-hunt that resulted in scoring 11,000 visits to a blog that wouldn’t have got 11 visits otherwise. For one reason or another, you have earned the attention of a blog. Depending on the situation, it’s likely that the best and most advisable course of action is to engage with that blog’s author and balance the POV with your own or even, gasp, act on the input.

10. Consider blogging as a tool
Don’t think of blogs as purely a dangerous manifestation of unfettered opinion and irresponsible ‘citizen journalism’. Blogs are so much more than that. They are a powerful medium of expression that is increasingly becoming an important barometer of public opinion and source of public voice. They are self-correcting in a way that conventional media aren't - people will correct a mistake on a blog faster than you can say 'nmkl pjkl ftmch'. And they're part of the revolution in social media that is changing the way people today communicate. They're not about to go away, in other words. By the way, this post is a very good case in self-correcting point!

You can actually use a blog as a highly effective platform for your company to engage with customers. Take some time out to have a look around and you’ll find that they’re actually a neat tool. You don’t have to have a million readers for a blog to matter, either. It’s better to have a few hundred people that want to interact with you than advertise to 100,000 that don’t. Remember, this is the era of the ‘long tail’. So think about joining ‘the conversation’. I think, after a while, you’ll be glad you did.


Duffy said...

in re anonymity: FWIW, it's not all bad. You frequently get far more honesty in anonymity than you would if they had to put their name on there. YMMV.

Duffy said...

in re anonymity: FWIW, it's not all bad. You frequently get far more honesty in anonymity than you would if they had to put their name on there. YMMV.

Abu Dhabi/UAE Daily Photo said...

The problem with anonymity is that people say things in a manner that they would never do to your face. Flaming is so much easier when you think no one can find out who you are.

As for the purpose of the post, I can only begin to imagine what inspired it.

alexander... said...

I've got a real problem with anonymouses - it's one of the things that started me blogging in the first place. OK, I've got a mouth... But at least it's got a name and a reputation attached to it and is prepared to bear the consequences for its mouthery.

I do feel strongly that anonymity promotes ugly behaviour purely because people believe their cruelty (it's never about kindness, is it?) is without consequence.

But the post is advice for corporates, not individuals. I do think that people representing companies that try to be anonymously positive or aggressive in the face of blog posts(and fail, because we can track back their IPs) are dangerous to the company. If it comes from a company URL, it's a company statement, no? If you don't allow every staff member to be a spokesperson, why allow them to comment on blogs?

What inspired the post? Ah, inspiration. It's never there when you look for it, is it?


sea life said...

I use a pseudo. because I love it, means a lot for me and represent my past.
Everybody has the right of choice :)BUT
regarding the anonymouse's comment from "Scooped", for me is obviously, that specially he wanted to hide his identity to protect himself.
Congratulation for you, you uncovered him!!!

Mars said...

i wish my family read this before making an arse of themselves...

samuraisam said...

Anonymity is good in some places, not so good in others; I've used one forum that requires you to publicly use your full name and there never seem to be any childish arguments and it would also seem that forum is the most productive I've ever seen on the internet.

On the topic of number 5, I had quite a fun time with a certain job recruitment agency on my blog, who responded by posting stuff about me being connected with credit card fraud (funnily enough, at that time I didn't even have a bank account or a credit card), they signed the comment as being from citibank. When I checked my logs it was from the job recruitment agency.

Keefieboy said...

When I started blogging in Dubai, all the bloggers used fake identities, and some of them went to great lengths to keep their real identity secret. Fearful of the long arm of the wossname. I still haven't quite got used to the idea that in Europe you can say whatever you like (within the limits of libel laws) and your right to do so is enshrined in Constitutions etc.

I do worry sometimes when I am being critical of certain companies - I know they don't read my blog, so it's a bit like kicking someone who's already down...

alexander... said...

If you look at the comments on the prior post 'Scooped', you'll see that the dialogue actually does back up some of the points I made in this post - which are meant to be positive and helpful guidance for companies when dealing with blogs.

My anonymous problem apart, I do think that people commenting on blogs from companies or organisations should let people reading know that they have a vested interest in their comments. Or be in danger of being 'outed'.

Blogs can be such a double-edged sword. I mean, look at Wal-Mart...

Tainted Female said...

I've been out of Dubai for a year now and I feel exactly the same way as Keefie... Except, I still have to hold on to pieces of Dubai and thus try to bite my tongue when it comes to certain things on the blog...

As for the post... WELL SAID!!!

i*maginate said...

Thank you.

Louise said...

Thanks for this, it was like a mini crash course in Blogging ettiquette. Yes... I am green....

aoc gold said...


(Part I)

Who has seen the wind?

Neither I nor you;

But when the leaves hang trembling,

The wind is passing through.

(Part II)

Who has seen the wind?

Neither you nor I;
But when the trees bow down their heads,

The wind is passing by.

~by wow powerleveling

From The Dungeons

Book Marketing And McNabb's Theory Of Multitouch

(Photo credit: Wikipedia ) I clearly want to tell the world about A Decent Bomber . This is perfectly natural, it's my latest...